Exempt from Overtime? Not So Fast. FLSA Requires Overtime be Paid to Working Foremen and Other First-Line Supervisors

Exempt from Overtime? Not So Fast. FLSA Requires Overtime be Paid to Working Foremen and Other First-Line Supervisors

‍

Introduction

Classifying employees as exempt from overtime can help businesses manage labor costs, but when it comes to working foremen and first-line supervisors, employers must follow specific guidelines set by the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). The FLSA mandates overtime pay for certain employees, including those in supervisory positions, even if they are paid a salary. Simply paying an employee a salary or giving them supervisory duties does not automatically exempt them from overtime pay. Misclassifying these roles can result in back wages, penalties, and legal challenges. Let’s explore what the FLSA says about overtime for working foremen and first-line supervisors.

FLSA Overtime Requirements and Misconceptions

The FLSA generally requires employers to pay employees time and a half for any hours worked over 40 in a workweek. While many managerial positions can be exempt from overtime under the white-collar exemptions (executive, administrative, and professional), these exemptions come with strict criteria.

One common misconception is that paying a supervisor or foreman a salary makes them automatically exempt from overtime. However, under FLSA guidelines, an employee’s job duties, not their compensation structure, determine whether they are exempt from overtime. Specifically, employees who spend the majority of their time on non-exempt duties, such as manual labor, must be paid overtime, regardless of their supervisory role or salary status.

FLSA Executive Exemption and Working Foremen

The executive exemption under the FLSA requires that the employee’s primary duty be management of the enterprise or of a recognized department. The employee must regularly supervise at least two or more full-time employees and have the authority to hire or fire other employees (or make significant recommendations on hiring decisions),

However, many working foremen and first-line supervisors split their time between supervisory duties and manual labor. If the primary responsibility of the foreman is physical work, such as working alongside their crew on a construction site or performing hands-on tasks in a manufacturing setting, they likely do not meet the FLSA’s exemption requirements and must be paid overtime. The FLSA Fact Sheet #17B (https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/fact-sheets/17b-overtime-executive) describes all the exemption criteria, and emphasizes that employees whose primary duty is not management (by their definition) or who do not regularly supervise two or more employees are non-exempt and entitled to overtime pay.

What About the Administrative or Professional Exemptions?

Here is Fact Sheet 17A defining all of the criteria for each category of exemption (https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/fact-sheets/17a-overtime). According to FLSA, the administrative exemption applies to employees whose primary duty is non-manual work related to management or business operations and who exercise discretion and independent judgment on significant matters. While this may apply to certain supervisory roles, it generally does not cover working foremen who engage in manual labor. Similarly, the professional exemption applies to employees whose work is predominantly intellectual and requires specialized education—criteria that rarely apply to working foremen or first-line supervisors.

In most cases, working foremen and first-line supervisors who spend a substantial amount of time on non-exempt duties will not qualify for either the administrative or professional exemptions.

Consequences of Misclassifying Employees

Misclassifying employees as exempt when they should be non-exempt can have serious consequences under the FLSA. These include:

- Back Wages: Employers may owe back wages for unpaid overtime, sometimes for a period of up to three years.

- Penalties: The Department of Labor (DOL) can impose civil penalties for willful violations, leading to additional fines.

- Legal Costs: Employees who feel they’ve been wrongly classified may sue for back pay, leading to costly settlements or litigation.

How to Ensure Compliance with FLSA Guidelines

To avoid the risk of misclassifying working foremen or first-line supervisors, employers should take the following steps:

1. Review Job Duties: Evaluate the actual job responsibilities of each supervisory employee. If the foreman spends a majority of their time on manual labor, they likely do not qualify for an exemption and should be classified as non-exempt.

2. Do Not Rely on Salary Alone: A salary does not automatically make an employee exempt from overtime. Review the FLSA Fact Sheet#17B to ensure that the employee meets all the requirements for executive, administrative, or professional exemptions.

3. Monitor Changes in Job Duties: Job roles evolve over time, so it’s important to regularly reassess employees' duties to ensure they are classified correctly.

4. Consult with Legal Experts: FLSA regulations can be complex. Consult with legal experts or HR professionals to ensure compliance and avoid penalties.

Conclusion

The FLSA makes it clear that job duties—not titles or salary—determine whether an employee is exempt from overtime. For working foremen and first-line supervisors, this means that even if they have leadership roles or receive a salary, they may still be entitled to overtime pay if they spend significant time performing non-exempt tasks. To stay compliant and avoid costly penalties, employers should regularly evaluate the duties of their supervisory employees and ensure they meet FLSA standards for exemption.

At Dyas HRD, we help businesses stay compliant with FLSA regulations and avoid costly misclassification errors. If you’re unsure about the classification of your working foremen or first-line supervisors, or if you need guidance on interpreting FLSA exemptions, we’re here to help. Contact Dyas HRD today for expert assistance in reviewing your employee classifications and ensuring your business complies with all FLSA overtime requirements.

‍