Why Fair Hiring and Compliance Still Matter Without Affirmative Action Requirements

The Changing Landscape of Federal Contractor Compliance

With the January 21, 2025, Presidential Action revoking Executive Order 11246, federal contractors are no longer required to implement affirmative action programs for minorities and females. This revocation, along with the federal rejection of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) programs, has sparked significant discussion about what compliance now looks like for federal construction and service & supply contractors.

While affirmative action is no longer mandated, the principles of fair hiring and equal employment opportunity (EEO) remain legal requirements under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and other federal employment laws. Federal contractors must continue to ensure non-discriminatory hiring and HR practices, or they risk legal, reputational, and financial consequences.

Affirmative Action vs. Equal Employment Opportunity: Understanding the Difference

It is essential to recognize that affirmative action and EEO compliance are not the same:

• Affirmative Action (Now Revoked for Minorities and Females)
  • Required federal contractors to implement specific, proactive steps to recruit, hire, and promote underrepresented groups.
  • Focused on statistical representation often referred to as Placement Goals and compliance benchmarks.
  • No longer required under federal law (except for veterans and individuals with disabilities).
• Equal Employment Opportunity (Still Required by Law)
  • Mandates that employers do not discriminate against any individual based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin (Title VII), age (ADEA), disability (ADA, Section 503), or veteran status (VEVRAA).
  • Prohibits discriminatory hiring, firing, promotions, pay, and other workplace practices.
  • Enforced by the EEOC and OFCCP to ensure fair treatment in employment decisions.

Despite the end of affirmative action mandates for minorities and females, EEO remains a legal and ethical obligation for all federal contractors.

Why Fair Hiring Practices Still Matter for Federal Contractors

1. Federal Contractors Are Still Subject to Anti-Discrimination Laws

Even without affirmative action requirements, Title VII, ADA, ADEA, VEVRAA, and other federal laws still prohibit discrimination in employment. Federal contractors must:

• Maintain hiring practices that focus on merit, skills, and qualifications rather than race, gender, or other protected characteristics.
• Ensure consistent evaluation criteria to prevent implicit bias in recruiting and promotions.
• Continue workplace policies that align with non-discrimination standards to avoid OFCCP audits and EEO legal claims.

2. OFCCP and EEOC Audits Will Continue

• It is expected that the Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs (OFCCP) will continue to monitor EEO compliance through audits and investigations.
• While audits will no longer review affirmative action benchmarks, they will likely focus on:
  • Hiring and compensation practices to ensure they are non-discriminatory.
  • Handling of workplace discrimination complaints and retaliation claims.
  • Pay equity and workforce transparency in federal contracting.

3. Fair Hiring Protects Contractors from Legal and Financial Risks

• Non-compliance with EEO laws can result in lawsuits, penalties, and contract disqualifications.
• Retaliation and discrimination claims are among the most expensive and damaging legal issues for employers.
• Companies that fail to document fair recruiting, hiring, promotion, and termination decisions may struggle to defend against legal challenges.

4. Great Workforce Practices Strengthens Business Success

• Maintaining diverse hiring pipelines can broaden access to talent and help attract top candidates.
• Companies that prioritize fair, unbiased hiring can build a more stable and high-performing workforce.
• Federal agencies and prime contractors may prioritize partnerships with companies that demonstrate strong workforce compliance and ethics.

How Federal Contractors Should Adapt to the New Compliance Framework

Even without affirmative action, federal contractors must ensure their hiring and HR management practices remain fair, transparent, and legally compliant. Basic steps to take include:

• Review and Update HR Policies – Ensure hiring, compensation, and workplace policies comply with EEO laws and non-discrimination standards.
• Conduct Regular Internal Process and Policy Reviews – Establish compliance reviews for recruiting, hiring, and promotion decisions to prevent discrimination risks.
• Train HR and Hiring Managers – Educate staff on legal EEO requirements and how to make fair, unbiased hiring decisions.
• Maintain Proper Documentation – Keep records of hiring decisions, promotion criteria, pay structures, and performance evaluations to protect against legal claims.
• Consider implementing Dyas HRD’s Non-Discrimination Plan of Action – Our framework helps federal contractors remain compliant while promoting ethical hiring and workplace management.

Dyas HRD Helps Federal Contractors Navigate Compliance

The elimination of affirmative action requirements does not mean an end to compliance obligations. Fair hiring and equal opportunity remain critical legal requirements under federal law. Contractors must take proactive steps to ensure their policies, hiring practices, and HR operations align with non-discrimination standards.

Dyas HRD specializes in compliance solutions for federal construction and service & supply contractors and subcontractors, ensuring that businesses meet their obligations under the new legal framework.

Contact Dyas HRD today to discuss how we can help you adapt to the changing compliance landscape. 

‍